11.16.26

New Jersey Appellate Division Clarifies the Scope of Workers’ Compensation Reopeners

On November 2, 2026, the New Jersey Appellate Division issued a Decision which provided valuable insight with respect to the issues and defenses that can be raised by the respondent in the case of Tighe v. Tighe Landscape Design, Inc.

The petitioner sustained a work-related injury in October 2015 when he fell from a truck bed while unloading boulders and landed on rocks. He underwent right shoulder surgery. In 2018, he received an award of 31% of partial total for the right shoulder injury, which included a rotator cuff and biceps injury with surgical repair. The final payment was made on June 15, 2020. On August 14, 2020, he timely filed an Application for Review (Reopener), alleging an increase in the pain, duration, and intensity of his symptoms. A Motion for additional treatment was filed, and testimony was presented from the petitioner and his expert. The employer did not present any fact or medical witnesses.

What was interesting about the litigation was the petitioner alleged and amended new conditions including cervical radiculopathy and right carpal tunnel syndrome.  Following a full trial, the Judge dismissed the Application for Review finding that the petitioner complained of symptoms that were consistent with the same symptoms he had since 2015.  Ultimately, she found no change in condition.

However, the Judge also dismissed that aspect of the claim for the right carpal tunnel and cervical issues concluding that these were filed beyond the 2 year statute of limitations.  She concluded that these conditions had manifested well before the Application for Review was filed.

On appeal, the Appellate Division agreed with the argument from the petitioner that contested the Judge’s conclusion that Reopeners are only available where the alleged increase in disability is attributable to a condition pled in the original claim.  It is important to keep in mind that the Court noted the case law makes it clear that it is only the essential that the petitioner show a subsequent increase in the extent of his incapacity and the Reopener can clearly be amended to include conditions not contemplated in the original claim.  The Court noted, respondents must be aware, that the petitioner can bring to the Court’s attention additional conditions and diagnosis related to the original injury that were not previous awarded so long as they do so within 2 years from the last payment made for the original award.

Nevertheless, the dismissal of the Application for Review was upheld on appeal.  The Court felt that the Judge was justified in reviewing the petitioner’s testimony and that of the medical expert in concluding that the conditions from which the petitioner complained had existed as far back as 2017 and there was no evidence of a change or increase in condition.

COMMENT:  While the Decision to dismiss the Motion and the claim itself is certainly helpful to the respondents, it must be noted that with respect to a Reopener, the petitioner is clearly entitled to add additional conditions and parts of the body so long as they do so within 2 years from the date of the last payment of benefits.

Related Attorney

Board of Directors & Workers' Compensation Co-Managing Partner

Related Industry

Related Practice

For additional details regarding our attorneys, our business activities, or if you would like to speak to a Weber Gallagher lawyer, please contact:

Media Contact

Valerie Lyons
Chief Marketing and Business Development Officer
267.765.4124
vlyons@wglaw.com