There have been several new New York workers’ compensation decisions from the Appellate Division over the past two weeks. The November 12 decisions were all good for the defense. The November 19 batch was a little more mixed, including one decision on a Section 114-a penalty that is particularly interesting.
Here is a rundown.
Miles v. New York City Transit Authority, 11/12/26
The Appellate Division affirmed the Board’s decision not to find a causally related occupational disease involving the claimant’s right wrist.
The claimant worked for New York City Transit Authority from 1994 to 2021, first as a train conductor and primarily as a construction flagger. He alleged that he developed repetitive-use injuries to multiple body parts. The problem with the right wrist was that the claimant had previously injured that same wrist at work in 1997 and had experienced pain afterward that never fully went away. His doctors, including the physician who performed an IME, were not aware of that history.
The Court upheld the Board’s rejection of claimant’s medical opinions on the wrist because the physicians did not have a complete understanding of the claimant’s relevant medical history. They did not consider the impact of the 1997 traumatic injury. Without credible medical evidence establishing causation, the right wrist claim failed.
This is a good reminder of how important a complete medical history can be when defending an occupational disease claim.
Hahnenfeld v. Good Samaritan Hospital, 11/12/26
Yes, there are still cases on COVID.
Here, the Third Department upheld the Board’s determination not to allow the claimant to amend her claim to include Long COVID. The claimant was a nurse who had an established work-related COVID claim from 2020. She later contracted COVID a second time in approximately December 2021 and then sought to relate numerous additional symptoms and conditions to Long COVID.
Long COVID does not necessarily need to be separately added to an established COVID claim where the medical evidence shows that the claimant developed long-term symptoms from the original infection. But the claimant still has the burden of proving that those problems are causally related to the established COVID claim.
The claimant alleged symptoms including pain in her thighs and knees, hand tremors, difficulty walking and standing, decreased exercise tolerance, tingling in her legs, anxiety and urinary incontinence. She also had other conditions, including an autoimmune disorder, hypertension and cancer.
The problem was causation. The medical evidence did not sufficiently account for the second COVID infection or the claimant’s other medical conditions. The Third Department therefore affirmed the Board’s finding that there was insufficient evidence connecting the claimed Long COVID symptoms to the original work-related COVID infection.
Bailey v. Caledonia Mumford Central School District, 11/12/26
This is a very good decision on notice.
Workers’ Compensation Law § 18 generally requires a claimant to give an employer written notice of an injury within 30 days. Here, the claimant, a school bus driver, injured her shoulder while trying to open the rear emergency door of a bus in February 2022.
She told the employer’s mechanic that the door was stuck, but she did not tell him that she had injured herself. She continued working and did not seek medical treatment for more than two months. She did not report the injury to the employer until September or October. The Board found that simply telling the mechanic that the door was stuck did not satisfy the notice requirement.
The twist was that the employer initially filed a First Report of Injury that incorrectly stated it had knowledge of the injury in February 2022. The Board did not find that statement dispositive because the other evidence established that the employer had not actually been notified of the injury at that time.
The Third Department affirmed. The Court also upheld the Board’s finding that the delay prejudiced the employer because it prevented the employer from obtaining a contemporaneous medical opinion.
And Then Came November 19…
The Third Department released another batch of workers’ compensation decisions this week, with several additional rulings worth noting.
Silva v. Consolidated Scaffolding, 11/19/26
In Silva, the claimant, a scaffold installer, was struck by a piece of iron while breaking down scaffolding. He went to the hospital two days later and then attempted to return to work. He told his foreperson that he was unable to work because of his injuries. Shortly afterward, his employment ended.
The claim was initially established for the right shoulder and was later amended to include neck and back injuries, post concussion syndrome and major depressive disorder. The employer and carrier also argued that the claimant had voluntarily removed himself from the labor market because he was terminated for alleged safety violations rather than because of his disability.
That argument failed. The foreperson testified that the claimant had violated safety regulations, but the employer did not produce documentation supporting those violations despite multiple requests that it do so. The Board credited the claimant’s testimony that he stopped working because of his injuries and found that his separation from employment was involuntary and due to his disability.
The Third Department affirmed, relying on the Board’s broad authority to resolve factual and credibility disputes.
The takeaway for employers is pretty straightforward: if a termination is based on safety violations or other misconduct unrelated to the injury, make sure those reasons are documented.
This may be the most perplexing decision of the week.
The claimant suffered a work-related back injury and was receiving benefits. On April 13, 2023, he attended an IME and reported pain at 10 out of 10, along with problems bending, walking and sleeping. The IME physician found a 75% orthopedic disability and restricted him to sedentary work with lifting and carrying of up to 10 pounds occasionally.
Unfortunately for the claimant, the carrier also conducted surveillance that day.
The footage showed him helping remove a power washer from a truck, carrying an aluminum ladder, climbing up and down the ladder, and power washing his house and fence for approximately 30 minutes.
The WCLJ found a violation of Workers’ Compensation Law § 114-a based on material misrepresentations about his condition and imposed the mandatory penalty. The Board later went further and imposed the discretionary penalty, permanently disqualifying the claimant from future indemnity benefits.
The Third Department agreed that there was a § 114-a violation, but reversed the permanent disqualification, finding it so disproportionate to the offense as to be “shocking to one’s sense of fairness.” The Court noted that there was no demonstrated pattern of misrepresentation and that the claimant had a significant back injury that ultimately required surgery less than a year later.
Apparently, the Third Department has a fairly forgiving sense of fairness.
What makes the decision interesting is that the underlying § 114-a violation remained intact. The issue was how far the penalty should go. The Court viewed permanent loss of future wage replacement benefits as too severe based on a single documented episode of misrepresentation, particularly given the claimant’s subsequent surgery.
For carriers, Hyde is worth watching. The decision suggests that even when proven that a claimant fakes his capabilities supporting a § 114-a violation that may not be enough to support permanent disqualification. The record supporting the severity and repeated nature of the misconduct may become increasingly important when seeking the discretionary penalty.
Schindlar v. Incorporated Village of Sands Point, 11/19/26
This case probably should not have been such a close call.
The claimant had an established right shoulder injury dating back to 2004. By August 2005, an employer consultant found that the shoulder injury had resolved. Then, 16 years later, the claimant sought authorization for rotator cuff surgery and attempted to relate the surgery back to the 2004 claim.
The request was denied. A second surgeon later sought authorization for essentially the same surgery under the 2004 claim, and it was denied again.
The problem was the medical proof. One surgeon had not reviewed the claimant’s records from 2004 and was unaware whether the claimant had received shoulder treatment during the intervening years. Another physician offered a causation opinion but did not provide a basis for it.
Given the minimal lost time following the original injury and the 17-year gap in treatment, the Third Department agreed that the Board could reject those causation opinions as unsupported.
Like Miles, this is another good causation decision for the defense. A doctor cannot simply rely on the existence of an old compensable injury to connect a new condition or surgery many years later.
Eusebio-Brito / Doumbia v. New York Black Car Operators, 11/19/26
These are two separate cases involving essentially the same issue: claimants’ permanency reports were precluded because the physicians did not comply with the IME requirements of Workers’ Compensation Law § 137.
In both cases, claimants’ counsel argued that the physician was a treating doctor and therefore did not have to comply with the stricter IME requirements. The Board disagreed.
The Third Department affirmed, finding that the physician was not providing substantive treatment at the time of the permanency examinations. Instead, the examinations were conducted for the purpose of determining maximum medical improvement, permanency and schedule loss of use. That made them IMEs subject to § 137. Because the statutory and regulatory requirements governing IME reports were not followed, the permanency reports were properly precluded.
Eusebio-Brito also had an interesting additional issue. The carrier’s IME report did not indicate that the physician used a goniometer to measure range of motion, but the doctor testified that he had, in fact, used one. The Board was entitled to credit that testimony and rely on his opinion finding a 0% schedule loss of use.
The takeaway: calling someone a treating physician does not make them one. If the examination is really being conducted to provide a permanency opinion rather than treatment, the § 137 IME requirements apply.
Finally, Lewis involved mostly a procedural issue.
The carrier sought to have the claimant’s current case travel together with two prior workers’ compensation claims so that his overall permanent impairment could be considered together. The Board declined, in part because the current case was ready for a permanency hearing while the other claims had not yet been established and involved different injury sites.
The Third Department did not reach the merits. Instead, it dismissed the appeal because the Board’s ruling was a nonfinal, interlocutory decision. The issue can be reviewed after a final Board decision rather than through a piecemeal appeal.
A Few Takeaways From a Busy Two Weeks
For additional details regarding our attorneys, our business activities, or if you would like to speak to a Weber Gallagher lawyer, please contact: